My First: Cheated, Creampied, Bred – Scarlett Rose

Scarlett admits to Oliver that she cheated on him while he was away during his first semester of college. Without giving her a chance to explain herself, Oliver dumps Scarlett, leaving her heartbroken and alone. She knows she fucked up, but she wants Oliver back, so she comes up with a failproof plan. Scarlett will tell Oliver she’s pregnant to get him to fall in love all over again. There is one issue – she needs someone to knock her up. The perfect candidate turns out to be Oliver’s dad, Will.